Freight quote comparison & margin calculator

Compare the whole offer. Check the margin before you quote.

Compare freight quotes with clear charges and service terms. Calculate broker margin, markup and target selling prices, with formulas and worked examples.

Free to use · no signup · calculations stay in your browser

Supplied quote comparison · internal worksheet

Compare supplied carrier quotes

Miami, FL 33166 → Atlanta, GA 30303 · 2026-11-10 · LTL · commercial delivery

Snapshot 2026-11-06T09:00 · UTC-05:00 · USD

Offer A
USD 420.00
Offer B
USD 444.00

EX-A-006 · 3 business days · estimated

EX-B-006 · 2 business days · estimated

Offer A is USD 24.00 lower for the matched scope.

Blue linehaul · orange fuel · green planned services

Offer A · USD 420.00
Offer B · USD 444.00
ChargeOffer A · USDOffer B · USD
Quoted linehaul350.00320.00
Linehaul floor top-up0.000.00
Fuel50.0064.00
Liftgate20.0060.00
AppointmentIncluded in another chargeIncluded in another charge
Additional planned serviceNot applicable to the offerNot applicable to the offer
Quoted total420.00444.00

Planned services describe the supplied quotes. Changes, waiting, reweigh or reclassification can change the invoice.

Open private margin calculator

One shipment request for both offers

Comparison snapshot

Edit the source offers

Offer A · source terms

Apply a quoted linehaul floor before calculating percentage fuel. The floor changes linehaul only.

Offer B · source terms

Apply a quoted linehaul floor before calculating percentage fuel. The floor changes linehaul only.

Private broker pricing worksheet

Cost base C · selling price S · selected additional direct expenses K. Count each direct cost once.

Manually entered cost base · USD

Gross profit on C
USD 80.00
Gross margin on sell
16.00%
Markup on C
19.05%
Selected-cost contribution
USD 60.00

Contribution rate 12.00% of sell. Overhead and tax are outside this selected-cost measure.

Target selling price
USD 525.00
Achieved margin
20.00%
Achieved markup
25.00%
Achieved contribution rate
16.19%
Customer quote details
Customer quote preview

Customer freight quote

Customer freight quote

Customer quote reference
Q-EXAMPLE-001
Selling price
USD 500.00
Origin
Miami, FL 33166
Destination
Atlanta, GA 30303
Pickup date
2026-11-10
Mode and service
LTL · commercial delivery
Finished handling units and gross weight
2 pallets · 48 × 40 × 45 in each · 900 lb total
Supplied class and handling
Class 100 · stackable · general goods, non-hazardous
Required services
Destination liftgate and delivery appointment
Destination liftgate required
Yes
Delivery appointment required
Yes
Customer transit terms
3 business days, estimated
Acceptance terms
Subject to capacity and confirmation for the stated shipment and services.
Internal comparison export preview

Internal freight comparison

Shipment and comparison snapshot

Origin
Miami, FL 33166
Destination
Atlanta, GA 30303
Pickup date
2026-11-10
Mode and service
LTL · commercial delivery
Finished handling units and gross weight
2 pallets · 48 × 40 × 45 in each · 900 lb total
Supplied class and handling
Class 100 · stackable · general goods, non-hazardous
Required services
Destination liftgate and delivery appointment
Destination liftgate required
Yes
Delivery appointment required
Yes
As of
2026-11-06T09:00 UTC-05:00
Comparison currency
USD
Comparison result
Offer A is USD 24.00 lower for the matched scope.

Offer A · source offer

Quote reference
EX-A-006
Quote currency
USD
Accept by
2026-11-09T17:00 UTC-05:00
Transit
3 business days · estimated
Eligibility
Eligible for shared request
Supplied linehaul
350
Linehaul floor
0
Fuel rule
50 USD
Quoted linehaul
350.00
Linehaul floor top-up
0.00
Fuel
50.00
Liftgate
20.00
Appointment
0.00
Additional planned service
0.00
Liftgate source status
Amount supplied
Appointment source status
Included in another charge · Linehaul
Additional planned service source status
Not applicable to the offer
Known subtotal
420.00
Source-currency total
420.00

Offer B · source offer

Quote reference
EX-B-006
Quote currency
USD
Accept by
2026-11-09T17:00 UTC-05:00
Transit
2 business days · estimated
Eligibility
Eligible for shared request
Supplied linehaul
320
Linehaul floor
0
Fuel rule
20% of linehaul after floor
Quoted linehaul
320.00
Linehaul floor top-up
0.00
Fuel
64.00
Liftgate
60.00
Appointment
0.00
Additional planned service
0.00
Liftgate source status
Amount supplied
Appointment source status
Included in another charge · Linehaul
Additional planned service source status
Not applicable to the offer
Known subtotal
444.00
Source-currency total
444.00

Private pricing · internal use

Cost source
Manually entered cost
Cost base (USD)
420
Sell (USD)
500
Selected additional expenses (USD)
20
Gross profit
80.00
Gross margin
16.00%
Markup
19.05%
Selected-cost contribution
60.00
Contribution rate
12.00%
Target method
Gross margin
Target percent
20
Target sell rounded up
525.00
Achieved gross margin at target
20.00%
Achieved markup at target
25.00%
Achieved contribution rate at target
16.19%
Pricing status
Priced

How to use the calculator

  1. Set one shipment request

    Match both offers on lane, pickup, cargo, handling and required accessorials. Confirm each quote covers the shared request.

  2. Enter charges and source terms

    Enter linehaul, the quoted fuel basis, any linehaul floor and planned services. Keep accept-by times and transit terms with the source.

  3. Compare at an explicit snapshot

    Select the snapshot and offsets. Resolve missing fees and scope differences. For mixed currencies, supply the FX rate, date and source.

  4. Review cost and customer sell

    Choose a cost base, add the customer sell and enter costs outside the base. Preview the customer copy separately from the internal comparison.

Quote checklist and formulas

Matched service scope

Compare the same cargo, dates and services. Terminal pickup and door delivery are different scopes. Bundles must name their priced parent.

Charges, minimums and fuel

Apply a linehaul-only floor before the sample percentage fuel calculation. Enter a flat fuel amount when the quote uses another base and you have calculated the charge.

Accept-by, transit and currency

Accept-by is inclusive. Transit remains estimated unless the provider expressly guarantees it. Manual FX converts the source total once.

Margin, markup and contribution

Gross profit = sell − cost. Gross margin divides profit by sell. Markup divides profit by cost. Selected-cost contribution subtracts the additional direct costs outside the cost base.

Target sell

Divide cost by (1 − target margin), multiply cost by (1 + target markup), or divide cost plus additional expenses by (1 − target contribution). Round the required sell up to the next cent if needed.

Worked examples

Compare USD 420 and USD 444

A: 350 linehaul + 50 fuel + 20 liftgate = 420. B: 320 + 20% of 320 + 60 = 444. The matched difference is 24.

Flag an unknown liftgate charge

B shows a known subtotal of USD 384. A missing required charge keeps the full comparison open.

Use a USD 400 linehaul floor

B becomes 400 + 80 fuel + 60 liftgate = USD 540.

Convert a supplied EUR quote

EUR 400 × a manually sourced example rate of 1.10 USD/EUR = USD 440.

Compare margin and markup

With USD 420 cost and USD 500 sell, gross profit is 80, gross margin is 16%, and markup is 19.05%.

Set a margin or markup target

At USD 420 cost, a 20% margin requires USD 525. A 20% markup requires USD 504.

Check contribution and a loss

An additional USD 20 of direct expenses leaves USD 60 contribution on a USD 500 sell. At USD 400 sell, gross profit is −20 and contribution is −40.

Frequently asked questions

What should I compare besides the rate?

Check the same shipment assumptions, included services, fuel basis, validity and estimated or guaranteed transit.

What happens when a charge is missing?

The known subtotal stays visible. Resolve the charge or confirm its inclusion or exclusion before using a complete quote total.

How do I handle a quoted fuel percentage?

Confirm the exact charge base. This sample applies percentage fuel to linehaul after the linehaul floor.

How do I compare offers in different currencies?

Enter the direction, rate, date and source for manual FX. The calculator preserves the source amounts and compares converted totals.

What is the difference between margin and markup?

Margin expresses gross profit as a share of selling price. Markup expresses the same profit as a share of cost.

Why does target sell round up?

A downward cent-rounding could leave the achieved rate below the target. At USD 100 cost and 25% margin, USD 133.34 meets the target.

What goes into the customer export?

The shipment details, customer price, customer quote reference, customer-facing transit and acceptance terms. Use the internal export to keep the underlying charges and pricing assumptions.

Will the quote total equal the final invoice?

Reweighs, classification changes, waiting time or new services can change the invoice. Check the carrier’s actual terms before booking.

Sources

Related resources