Free 3PL cost comparison calculator

Compare two fulfillment quotes on the same workload.

Compare 3PL receiving, storage, pick and pack, returns, monthly minimums and setup fees. See a monthly cost breakdown and cost per order.

Free to use · no signup · calculations stay in your browser

Two supplied quotes · one billing month

Recurring monthly fees

1000 orders · 2026-11 · Warehouse services only

Provider A
USD 3,100.00
Provider B
USD 3,450.00
Provider A · USD 3.10 / orderProvider B · USD 3.45 / order

Provider A is USD 350.00 lower per month.

Blue order fees and minimum top-up · orange storage · green other fees

Provider A · USD 3,100.00
Provider B · USD 3,450.00
ServiceProvider A · USDProvider B · USD
Receiving200.00250.00
Storage400.00500.00
Order fee1750.001800.00
Additional picks150.00200.00
PackagingIncluded150.00
Returns100.00100.00
Project labor200.00250.00
Account fee300.00200.00
Custom recurring feeNo chargeNo charge
Minimum top-up0.000.00
Known subtotal3100.003450.00
Complete monthly total3100.003450.00

One workload for both quotes

The sample excludes outbound postage, inbound freight, tax, duty and insurance. Compare the same services in each offer.

Order mix

Use one group per distinct number of picked units. The group counts must add up to fulfilled orders.

Edit the quotes

Provider A rates

Minimum and one-time setup

Provider B rates

Minimum and one-time setup
One-time fees and horizon

Setup is charged once. Enter a positive whole number of months to see a fixed-workload comparison.

Provider A

First month
USD 3,100.00
Horizon total
USD 37,200.00
Normalized month
USD 3,100.00

Provider B

First month
USD 3,450.00
Horizon total
USD 41,400.00
Normalized month
USD 3,450.00
Preview comparison summary

3PL cost comparison summary

Shared workload

Billing month
2026-11
Shared service scope
Warehouse services only
Fulfilled orders
1000
Received pallets
20
Billed pallet-months
20
Returns
20
Project hours
5
Chargeable days
30
Horizon months
12
Order group 1
500 orders × 1 picks
Order group 2
500 orders × 2 picks
Comparison
Provider A is USD 350.00 lower per month.

Provider A · USD

Provider
Provider A
Scope confirmed
Yes
Included units per order
1
Extra picks
500
Storage basis
Billed pallet-months
Source storage rule
Contractual billed pallet-months
Minimum
1500
Minimum eligibility confirmed
Yes
Minimum at zero orders
yes
Eligible recurring charges
1900.00
Minimum top-up
0.00
Known monthly subtotal
3100.00
Complete monthly total
3100.00
Cost per order
3.10
Setup
0.00
First month
3100.00
Fixed-workload horizon total
37200.00
Normalized monthly cost
3100.00

Provider A itemized fees

Receiving
Receiving · Rate supplied · 20 × 10 USD · 200.00
Storage
Storage · Rate supplied · 20 × 20 USD · 400.00
Order fee
Order fee · Rate supplied · 1000 × 1.75 USD · 1750.00
Additional picks
Additional picks · Rate supplied · 500 × .30 USD · 150.00
Packaging
Packaging · Included in another line · Parent: Order fee · 0.00
Returns
Returns · Rate supplied · 20 × 5 USD · 100.00
Project labor
Project labor · Rate supplied · 5 × 40 USD · 200.00
Account fee
Account fee · Rate supplied · 1 × 300 USD · 300.00
Custom recurring fee
Custom recurring fee · Confirmed no charge · 0.00

Provider B · USD

Provider
Provider B
Scope confirmed
Yes
Included units per order
1
Extra picks
500
Storage basis
Billed pallet-months
Source storage rule
Contractual billed pallet-months
Minimum
1800
Minimum eligibility confirmed
Yes
Minimum at zero orders
yes
Eligible recurring charges
2000.00
Minimum top-up
0.00
Known monthly subtotal
3450.00
Complete monthly total
3450.00
Cost per order
3.45
Setup
0.00
First month
3450.00
Fixed-workload horizon total
41400.00
Normalized monthly cost
3450.00

Provider B itemized fees

Receiving
Receiving · Rate supplied · 20 × 12.50 USD · 250.00
Storage
Storage · Rate supplied · 20 × 25 USD · 500.00
Order fee
Order fee · Rate supplied · 1000 × 1.80 USD · 1800.00
Additional picks
Additional picks · Rate supplied · 500 × .40 USD · 200.00
Packaging
Packaging · Rate supplied · 1000 × .15 USD · 150.00
Returns
Returns · Rate supplied · 20 × 5 USD · 100.00
Project labor
Project labor · Rate supplied · 5 × 50 USD · 250.00
Account fee
Account fee · Rate supplied · 1 × 200 USD · 200.00
Custom recurring fee
Custom recurring fee · Confirmed no charge · 0.00

How to use the calculator

  1. Set the billing month and workload

    Enter orders, picked units by order group, inbound pallets, billable storage, returns and labor.

  2. Match the services and fee basis

    Use the same service scope. Enter each rate against the unit the quote actually uses and identify bundled services.

  3. Apply the monthly minimum

    Mark only eligible charges. Check how the contract treats zero-activity months and any separate account fee.

  4. Compare recurring costs and setup

    Compare the monthly total and cost per fulfilled order. Review setup separately and verify still-open terms before committing.

Fee checklist and formulas

Receiving and storage

Use each contract’s named billing quantity. Pallet-days sum daily occupancy, while billed pallet-months and volume-months follow the stated contract basis.

Order fees, extra picks and packaging

Extra picks = sum of group orders × max(picked units per order − included picks, 0). A charge included in a priced parent adds zero.

Returns, projects and account charges

Use the rate per return, project hour or month. Add a custom named line when the proposal quotes a separate recurring service.

Minimum, setup and comparison scope

Top-up = max(0, minimum − eligible fees). Recurring fees exclude setup. Setup is added once over a fixed-workload horizon.

Worked examples

Compare a 1,000-order month

Provider A totals USD 3,100 or 3.10/order. Provider B totals USD 3,450 or 3.45/order for the same services.

Raise a monthly minimum

A minimum of USD 2,500 against USD 1,900 eligible adds a USD 600 top-up. A totals USD 3,700.

Test low and peak workloads

At 500 orders the two sample totals are USD 2,550 and 3,000. At 2,000 orders they become USD 5,700 and 6,450.

Use a daily storage basis

20 pallets present for 30 days create 600 pallet-days. At USD 0.65 per pallet-day storage costs USD 390.

Resolve unknown packaging

When B has not quoted packaging, its known monthly subtotal is USD 3,300. Complete totals and the comparison wait for an answer.

Separate setup from recurring cost

Enter USD 600 and USD 1,200 for setup. At the sample volumes, 12 months plus setup cost USD 37,800 and USD 42,600.

Frequently asked questions

What fees should I ask a 3PL to quote?

Ask about receiving, storage, handling, picks, packaging, returns, projects, account fees, minimums and one-time setup. Confirm outbound postage and other exclusions.

How do I compare cost per order?

Divide the complete recurring monthly cost by fulfilled orders. A month with zero orders has no cost-per-order ratio.

How are extra picks calculated?

Subtract the included picks per order from each group of like orders and sum the chargeable excess. Spare picks on one order do not offset another.

How do bundled fees work?

Link the bundled service to a single priced line and confirm its scope. This avoids charging twice and duplicating minimum credit.

How does a monthly minimum work?

Add the shortfall between the contract minimum and eligible charges. Verify the included services and treatment at zero orders.

Can I compare quotes with different storage bases?

Yes, when both quotes describe the same inventory workload and you supply each contract’s own billable quantities and rates.

Can I compare quotes in different currencies?

Use quotes in the same currency to compare rates. The calculator does not infer an FX rate.

Are these rates market benchmarks?

The worked quotes are synthetic. Enter actual rates for the same workload and check contractual tiers, terms and exclusions.

Sources

Related resources